Student Engagement: Best Practices for Hybrid and In-Person Classes

Getting your students’ attention? Not an easy feat. Keeping their attention? One of teaching’s greatest challenges. After the disruption of the past couple years, student engagement has never been more difficult.

Whether remote, in-person, or hybrid, getting students to stay focused can feel like an impossible feat. Student engagement is essential, but it doesn’t always come easy.

Today’s educators must be agile, with the ability to adapt to any setting where learning takes place. As you navigate hybrid classrooms or return to in-person learning, here’s how you can keep your students’ attention, increase engagement, and improve retention.

The 4 Dimensions of Student Engagement

Student engagement widely consists of four distinct components: behavioral, emotional, cognitive, and agentic. Motivating students in each of these four areas is the key to keeping students engaged in any classroom setting.

Behavioral engagement consists of all learning-related activities that take place both inside and outside the classroom. At a deeper level, behavioral engagement also involves a student’s ability to effectively follow established classroom norms.
Emotional engagement encompasses the social and emotional responses from students in their interactions with teachers and peers. This type of engagement can be both positive or negative, represented through emotions such as excitement, happiness, boredom, or anxiety.

Cognitive engagement refers to things like processing, or the amount of time students spend working on course-related activities or material. Often, cognitive engagement can be measured through the quality of the work students are submitting or the level of participation from students during small group activities.

Agentic engagement is the ability for a student to take a proactive approach to their learning. Actions such as providing feedback on a lesson or addressing a skills gap with an instructor are both indicators of agentic engagement.

As educators transition from remote to hybrid and in-person learning, best practices for student engagement all start with creating an environment with each of these engagement types in mind.

A student answers a question while learning at home on their tablet. — Remote student engagement is possible with the right planning and some creativity.

The Right Material for the Right Environment

Not all activities can take place effectively online. As you outline your course, consider the modules or activities that are best for in-person learning and the ones that can be completed online. Labs and experiments are a great example of in-person activities. Silent reading, writing or independently paced lessons that can be completed asynchronously are great examples of activities best for online learning days.

It’s important to keep in mind that not all students have the skills needed to adapt to learning in different classroom settings. One way to ensure access and inclusivity for all students is to incorporate the Universal Design for Learning strategies suggested by the National Education Association.

For elementary students, it’s important to start by gauging the understanding of your students as you progress through your lesson. In an in-person setting, you may rely largely on facial expressions, body language and verbal feedback to do so.

For hybrid students learning remotely, things get a little more challenging. You can’t have students coming off mute every two minutes to say if they understand the material or not. Try to give students opportunities to share their understanding throughout the lesson in fun and creative new ways. For example, you can have students ask and answer short questions via chat. More on that later.

In a high school or higher-education setting, set clear expectations for how and when you can be reached for questions about assignments by utilizing office hours, both virtually and in-person.

Make Space for Socialization and Meaningful Discussion

For middle and high-school students, the discussion format is one of the most popular options for in-person and remote learning. Hybrid classes can accommodate this set-up through break-out rooms.

Here’s how:

Start by providing your students with an open-ended prompt on a relevant topic.
Divide students into pairs or small groups through break-out rooms.
Have students discuss their thoughts for a set amount of time.
Ask students to note their key ideas in a Google Doc.
Use a round-robin format to allow each group to share their discussion.
As other groups present, students can jot down their thoughts on the information and presentations in a Google Sheet.

This virtual take on the traditional discussion allows for personal and group reflection while strengthening written and verbal communication skills.
Missing the conversations that tend to flow before and after class? For higher-education settings, consider giving students a few minutes to socialize before getting started, or hold open office hours on the classroom video channel after class ends.

Consider providing a place for discussion with a classroom lounge. To make it more inclusive for a hybrid setting, add a virtual forum and share material you otherwise wouldn’t be able to get to in class for students to interact with. To keep it fun, play trivia or post links to interesting subtopics to spark casual conversation.

Making Your Classroom Interactive for Stronger Student Engagement

Incorporating interactive learning opportunities is one of the most effective ways to maximize cognitive engagement.

For elementary students, games are the perfect way to add that interactive element to the learning experience. Using a Vibe Smart Whiteboard, students from all locations can join together to play fun and engaging games such as Kahoot, story sequence, Pictionary, and more.

Using interactive games and other multimedia types can also be effective for engagement at the high school level or in a higher education setting. In a recent study, educators found that thoughtfully selecting digital activities led to significantly greater student engagement.

These different strategies don’t have to be limited to only synchronous or asynchronous settings. For example, Vibe Smart Whiteboards integrate with a variety of video-conferencing platforms, meaning live debates can take place in real time with both in-person and remote students.

In Higher Education

In higher education, consider the “Students as Partners,” or SaP approach. The SaP approach works to reverse the norm that faculty are the single experts on a particular topic by giving all participants the opportunity to engage as they would on a peer to peer level.

While instructors are experts at knowing what to teach, students are experts at knowing how they learn. According to the research, by giving students an active role in deciding how they learn, it creates a classroom environment where students can share new perspectives and ultimately gain a deeper understanding of course material.

{{< blog/cta-download-new content="Future of Learning" extra="false" pdf="https://vibe.us/pdf/future-of-hybrid-learning/?utm_campaign=student-engagement-blog&utm_medium=blog&utm_source=blog">}}

Explore How Students Want to Learn

a group students are learning — Students gathered around laptops

While all-remote learning has its advantages and challenges, one of the biggest pros is the ability for students to engage with a lesson at their own pace through asynchronous learning.

On the other hand, one of the biggest cons is missing out on valuable feedback from learners. As educators and students transition back to the classroom, it’s important to make sure all students have the opportunity to remain stakeholders in their learning experience.

In fact, the higher-education study referenced in the last section noted that when students were put in charge of the content in a leading position, that experience enhanced both emotional and cognitive engagement.

Here are a few ways to empower your students to get involved in their learning:

For a quick temperature check, request thumbs up or thumbs down emojis. You may even have students share their favorite and least favorite emojis to serve as a “Yes, I get it” or “No, I need help” to put a more creative spin on things.

Need to do a quick overview of yesterday’s concepts? Try a Zoom chat quiz. These informal tests don’t have to be graded. Instead, they can help you determine what to review and what to move onto next. For best results, stick to a handful of key questions. You can try True/False or multiple choice for easy scanning of responses.

Classroomscreen recently added a polling feature that allows educators to get open feedback from students related to the lesson of the day. The polling feature is completely customizable and students can access it directly from a Vibe Smart Whiteboard.

Elevating Student Engagement With Vibe

teacher using Vibe Smartboard — Teacher using a Vibe Smart Whiteboard with remote students

Did we mention just how engaging a Vibe Smart Whiteboard can make your course material? Vibe is a perfect solution for enhancing student engagement in any classroom setting — hybrid or in person.

You’ll love working with students in real-time, sharing canvases and bringing some of that in-person interaction to the remote classroom. Check out our Vibe FAQs to learn more and request a quote for your school here.